As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

Hamilton Beach 25361 Review: Indoor Searing Trade-offs

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this review was made: We did not cook on this grill. Hamilton Beach’s exact 25361 page supplies specifications; Kohl’s and Lowe’s owner reviews provide reported strengths and complaints. We do not claim a measured smoke output or lifespan. Our method.

Depends

Convenient lidded indoor grilling with a real cleanup advantage, but not smoke-free.

The Hamilton Beach 25361 has a windowed lid, adjustable 200–450°F temperature and removable grill plate and drip tray. Published owner accounts frequently praise easy cleanup and straightforward searing. A smaller number describe smoke with fatty or marinated foods. This is practical indoor grilling, not a perfect outdoor-charcoal replacement.

Check current price on Amazon → Prices and availability change often, so we don't list them here.

Buy it again if you…

  • need a countertop grill with a lid and visible cooking window
  • want a removable nonstick plate and accessible drip tray
  • cook burgers or vegetables in modest batches

Skip it if you…

  • expect zero smoke or outdoor-charcoal flavor
  • need very high-capacity grilling for parties
  • prefer a contact press that grills both sides simultaneously

An indoor grill does not need to imitate a charcoal fire to be worthwhile. For a small household, the appeal is leaving the outdoor setup behind and cleaning a shallow removable grate instead of a full griddle.

The 25361 is the version with a viewing window. Its removable lid and adjustable heat distinguish it from closed contact grills, which can cook both sides at once but do not offer the same open-grate approach.

What owners say, at a glance

450°Fmaximum selected temperatureHamilton Beach
118 in²listed cooking surfaceKohl’s
25361exact lid-window modelHamilton Beach
Searing convenience
Adjustable high heat
Cleanup access
Removable parts
Batch size
Countertop portions
Smoke control
Food-dependent
Coating longevity
Owner anecdotes only

Bars are editorial visual summaries, not measured satisfaction percentages, survey results or laboratory scores.

The key specs

ModelHamilton Beach 25361, window-lid searing grill
TemperatureSelectable from 200°F to 450°F, manufacturer claim
Cooking surface118 square inches, retailer specification
PartsRemovable lid, nonstick grill grate and drip tray
IndicatorsPower and preheat lights
Grill typeSingle heated bottom grate; not a two-plate press
The Complete Meal Planning Journal — View on Amazon

What testers and owners appreciate

Cleanup.Removable cooking and drip components are the feature most consistently praised in the retailer summaries. The body itself still needs careful wiping and must not be submerged.
Visible cooking.The lid window lets you check browning without opening it on every glance, though steam and grease can obscure the glass.
High sear setting.A 450°F selectable setting broadens use beyond gentle warming. Independent owner reviews describe useful sear marks but are not calibrated temperature measurements.

What to consider before placing it indoors

Smoke is still possible.An owner report notes smoke with marinades at higher heat. Food fat, drips and kitchen ventilation matter.
The lid is not a press.You may need to turn food. The lid contains splatter, but it does not add a heated top plate.
Batch size is finite.A published 118-square-inch grate is convenient for a couple but not a substitute for an outdoor grill on family-party days.

Long-term care and coating questions

The current manufacturer calls the grate ceramic nonstick. Some historical retail content describes earlier nonstick materials; use the coating and care directions attached to the exact purchased version. We did not find a controlled multi-year coating test of 25361. Isolated owner reports mention chipped coating, but these cannot estimate a defect rate.

Clear grease from the drip tray after each use, let the grate cool, and avoid metal utensils or abrasive scrubbing. Check the lid and removable plate are properly seated before heating.

Practical setup tips

  • Use ventilation and do not promise yourself smoke-free cooking.
  • Keep space around the hot housing and under upper cabinets.
  • Check actual food temperature with a separate thermometer, not just surface setting.
  • Compare contact-grill models if you want top-and-bottom cooking without turning.

Pros and cons

What owners love

  • Windowed lid for monitoring
  • 200–450°F adjustment
  • Removable grate and drip tray
  • Positive owner cleaning feedback

What owners complain about

  • Smoke possible with certain foods
  • Not a two-sided contact press
  • Limited large-batch surface
  • Coating life not independently proven

Alternatives worth weighing

Compare the exact size and version before choosing.

ProductTrade-offConsider it if…
Hamilton Beach 25361 (this review)Covered open grillYou want visibility and removable grateSee on Amazon
Ninja Foodi Smart Indoor Grill
Read our review
Multi-function heated applianceYou want extra cooking modesSee on Amazon
George Foreman 4-Serving GRP1060BHeated contact grillYou want pressing from both sidesSee on Amazon

Should this model go on your shortlist?

Check the exact 25361 listing and read the cleaning instructions before ordering.

See it on Amazon →

Frequently asked questions

Is this grill smoke-free?

No countertop grill can guarantee that. Food fat and heat level affect smoke.

Can the grill plate come out?

Yes. Hamilton Beach lists a removable nonstick grate, lid and drip tray.

Does the lid cook from above?

No. This is not a heated two-sided contact press.

Can it replace a food thermometer?

No. Use a suitable thermometer for safe internal cooking temperatures.

Sources we analyzed

Figures reflect each source as of November 16, 2026 and may change. We summarize owner feedback in our own words and do not reproduce retailer reviews.