NYX Butter Gloss Review: Would Buyers Buy It Again?
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you buy through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this review was made: We did not test this gloss ourselves. The reviews we could read are from beauty bloggers, one of them dating from 2013, and neither covers the Praline shade specifically. The Amazon page defaults to Praline but the product comes in many shades. Findings describe the line in general. Our method.
A creamy, wearable, low-commitment gloss
Beauty reviewers describe Butter Gloss as buttery and lightly tinted with a pleasant vanilla or sweet scent, handy over matte lipsticks. Complaints are a thick, slightly sticky feel when layered, only a few hours of wear, and some pastel shades looking chalky on deeper skin tones. The evidence is blogger-based and the reviews are of the line, not of Praline specifically, but the overall pattern is positive enough to call it a repeat for people who like a soft, sheer gloss.
Check current price on Amazon → Prices and availability change often, so we don't list them here.Buy it again if you…
- like a sheer, creamy, lightly tinted gloss
- want a gloss to layer over matte lipsticks
- enjoy a sweet scented lip product
Skip it if you…
- dislike any tackiness or the feel of gloss on lips
- want opaque, long-wearing color
- have deeper skin tones and want a very pigmented shade (check the shade you pick)
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss is a drugstore lip gloss with a creamy, buttery texture and a light tint. The Amazon page defaults to the shade Praline, a warm nude tone, and lists the full shade range in the shade selector. Reviewers have counted dozens of shades across the regular and Intense versions.
This review summarizes user experiences and is not medical advice. If you have a known sensitivity to cosmetics or lip products, check the ingredient list on the pack and stop use if irritation occurs.
What owners say, at a glance
Bars show our editorial summary of how consistently owners praise or complain about each area across all sources — not a lab measurement.
What to know about the line
| Finish | Glossy, buttery, lightly tinted |
|---|---|
| Color | Sheer to medium, depending on shade |
| Scent | Sweet, vanilla or sugar-cookie-like per reviewers |
| Shade on the Amazon page | Praline (default); other shades available |
What reviewers like
What reviewers dislike
How it holds up over time
Gloss is a low-risk, low-commitment product. We found no long-term durability reports, and the reviews we read are older and blogger-based, so the formula may have changed. We cannot confirm how Praline specifically wears.
Tips
- Apply thinly to keep stickiness down.
- Try the Intense version if you want more color, per Lab Muffin.
- Layer over lip color for shine.
Pros and cons
What owners love
- Creamy, comfortable feel
- Pleasant sweet scent
- Works well over matte lipsticks
- Large shade range
What owners complain about
- Sheer color in many shades
- Can feel tacky when layered
- Wears off in a few hours
- Pale shades may not flatter deeper skin tones
Other lip products buyers compare
These are common alternatives for shine or color on the lips.
| Product | Style | Consider it if… | |
|---|---|---|---|
| NYX Butter Gloss (this review) | Creamy, lightly tinted gloss | You like a soft, sheer, scented gloss | See on Amazon |
| NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Read our review | Lip oil gloss | You want a more glass-like oil finish from the same brand | See on Amazon |
| Vaseline Lip Therapy Creme Brulee Read our review | Lip balm | You mainly want moisture rather than shine | See on Amazon |
Looking for an easy everyday gloss?
Check shades and current options on Amazon.
Frequently asked questions
Is it very sticky?
Reviewers describe it as slightly tacky, and stickier in thick layers.
How long does it last?
Reviewers report about a few hours without much eating or drinking.
Does it have a lot of color?
Mostly sheer to medium, depending on shade. The Intense version is more pigmented per one reviewer.
Is the Amazon page only Praline?
Praline is the default shade, but the page offers other shades.
Save this review for later
Pin it, share it, or send it to someone who's shopping for one.
Sources we analyzed
- Lab Muffin Beauty Science: NYX Butter Gloss and Intense Butter Gloss — texture, wear, stickiness, shade range
- Musings of a Muse: NYX Butter Gloss Review & Swatches — texture, wear, shade-range feedback (2013 review)
Figures reflect each source as of October 21, 2026 and may change. We summarize owner feedback in our own words and do not reproduce retailer reviews.